Boston, Cobbler, French Shakers: What Makes Them Different?

Boston, Cobbler, and French shakers- these are styles of cocktail shakers, all catering to different bartending needs.

The Boston shaker has a metal bottom and glass or metal top, and is versatile and preferred by pros for durability and ease of use.

The Cobbler shaker has a built-in strainer, making it beginner-friendly and less messy.

The all-metal French shaker has a sleek design but requires a separate strainer and more skill. Read on to find out more.

Summary

• Boston shakers have a metal bottom and glass top, which allows visibility during mixing.
• Cobbler shakers have a built-in strainer and lid, which is perfect for beginners.
• French or Parisian shakers are all metal and valued for a professional look.
• Unlike the all-in-one Cobbler, Boston and French shakers require a separate strainer.
• Pros prefer Boston shakers for larger capacity and versatility.

Boston Shaker

The Boston shaker, with a metal bottom and glass top, is the simplest and most efficient in the bartending world. As a pro, you’ll love its versatility and visibility. You can see right through the glass top, so you can judge the mix’s colour and consistency as you shake. It is perfect for chilling and mixing ingredients fast for quick service during busy hours.

And cleaning is a breeze, just separate the two parts and wash. But mastering the Boston Shaker takes practice. You need to learn how to seal it properly to avoid any spillage, but once you do it becomes an invaluable tool in your mixology kit.

Cobbler Shaker

For newcomers to mixology, a Cobbler shaker is a metal body with a built-in strainer and lid designed for ease and simplicity.

This 3-piece shaker makes it super easy to mix up your favourite cocktails with no fuss. You don’t need to buy a separate strainer, simplifying your bartending kit and clean-up process.

The cobbler shaker design is perfect for beginners or those who prefer a less messy bartending experience.

For beginners, the Cobbler shaker is a straightforward, less messy way to make your favourite cocktails.

But keep in mind it’s a bit less versatile than the Boston shaker and can be harder to clean due to the multiple parts.

But for ease of use right from the start, it’s hard to beat.

French Shaker

Entering the world of professional bartending, you’ll likely encounter the French shaker, also known as the “Parisian” shaker. This two-piece shaker is all metal and has a professional look that’s hard to miss.

It’s not just looks; it’s also very practical. Many bartenders prefer it for its sleek design, which makes shaking and chilling ingredients a breeze.

You’ll find it durable and easy to use, but it can be noisy when you’re in the thick of mixing.

Some say it’s less intuitive than Boston Shakers, but its aesthetic appeal often wins.

How do French Shakers differ from Boston and Cobbler Shakers?

You may already know the basic concept of cocktail shakers, but understanding how French shakers differ from Boston and Cobbler shakers will improve your bartending skills.

French shakers differ significantly in that they require a separate strainer, unlike the Cobbler shakers which have a built in one. This feature improves their sleek, professional look but demands more skill.

French shaker pros are durability and stylish design, perfect for pros.

French Shaker vs Boston Shaker

Now that we’ve seen how French shakers differ from Cobbler and Boston shakers in design and usage let’s compare French shakers with Boston shakers.

The French shaker is all metal, with two pieces of tin and a lid. All metal makes it more durable and less prone to breakage than the Boston shaker, which is a metal tin and glass mixing vessel. However, the Boston shaker has more capacity to mix more liquid at once. The French shaker has a tighter seal and fewer spills but can be harder to open after shaking.

Choose based on your preference for durability or capacity.

French Shaker vs Cobbler Shaker

If you’re deciding between a French shaker and a Cobbler shaker for your cocktail mixing needs, then you need to understand their differences.

Cobbler shakers are more manageable for beginners as they come with a built-in strainer. You don’t need to buy a separate strainer to filter out ice and herbs from your drinks. They’re perfect if you want simplicity and convenience in your bartending adventures.

French shakers are more stylish and elegant, fit well in upscale settings but require a bit more finesse. They don’t have a strainer so you need to master using a separate one.

Choosing between them depends on your preference for ease or style.

How do French Shakers compare to Boston Shakers in durability?

Now that we’ve seen the ease of use and style differences between French and Cobbler shakers let’s see how French shakers compare to Boston shakers in durability.

• Material Quality: French shakers often have high quality stainless steel, same as Boston shakers, for longevity and resistance to dents and corrosion.
• Seal Integrity: Unlike Boston shakers which may show wear at the glass and metal interface, French shakers have a consistent seal due to all metal construction.
• Professional Use: Both shaker types can withstand heavy use in professional settings, but French shakers have fewer parts, so they have fewer failure points.
• Maintenance: With no extra parts like the Cobbler and French shakers, Boston shakers are slightly easier to maintain but both are durable in busy environments.

Which shaker to use for frequent use

Which shaker should you reach for when mixing drinks frequently? If you’re leaning towards the Boston or Cobbler shakers, consider the nuances of your cocktail-making experience.

The Boston shaker, preferred by many professional bartenders, has excellent versatility and more capacity to mix multiple cocktails efficiently. Its two-piece design, although no built-in strainer, allows for faster mixing and a better feel for the cocktail’s temperature and texture. However, the Cobbler shaker with its built-in strainer is a more straightforward, albeit slower option.

Good for beginners but may slow you down if speed is important in your routine.

Last Orders

In summary, choosing the right shaker for your bartending needs depends on your preferences and the specifics of your cocktail-making process. The Boston shaker has versatility and visual control, the Cobbler shaker simplifies with its built in strainer, the French shaker has elegance and functionality. Each has its pros, so consider your frequency of use, need for convenience and durability when choosing. Gear up wisely and level up your mixology game to impress and flavour.

Related Articles

• Professional Bartender’s Choice: Boston vs Cobbler vs French Shakers