Up to 40% off
Glassware
Shop
Bar Accessories
Get 30% off
Tableware
Shop
Refrigeration
Save Up To 30%
Front of House
Shop
Kitchen Accessories
Shop
Catering Equipment
Shop
Cleaning
Get 30% off
Disposables
What is a Professional Bartender’s Choice? When choosing between types of cocktail shakers like: Boston, Cobbler, and French shakers consider your needs.
Boston shakers are great for speed and volume, mixing multiple drinks fast but require a separate strainer.
Cobbler shakers have built-in strainers, great for beginners but can be a pain to clean.
French shakers are sleek and durable but you need extra tools like a strainer to make your bar look nice.
Each has its pros, and further reading will reveal which one is best for your bar.
You might wonder why the Boston shaker is the go-to for pros. Its design and functionality make it stand out. Fundamentally, it’s two parts—a mixing glass and a metal tin that fits together snugly.
But while these features make cocktail mixing quick and easy to pour, they can be a problem if the seal is too tight or hard to separate after shaking.
While many cocktail shakers get attention, the Boston shaker stands out because of its rugged design and functionality. As a professional bartender you’ll love the Boston shaker’s two-part system—a large metal tin paired with a smaller one. This isn’t just sleek, it’s functional, making cocktail mixing smoother and faster.
Easy to clean and large capacity means you can mix multiple drinks at once. Whether you’re shaking up a storm on a busy night or crafting a complex cocktail, the Boston shaker’s design and functionality makes it the top choice for pros.
The Boston shaker consists of a simple two-piece design, one glass and one metal tin that fits together snugly.
It’s a pro bar favourite for its large capacity, which means you can shake multiple drinks at once. A common staple in professional bars because you can shake multiple cocktails at once, including complex recipes with egg whites.
This type of shaker is a favourite among bartenders for its reliability and speed of service, making it one of the most versatile cocktail tool. Plus it’s super easy to clean, so you can keep your bar tidy.
Immerse yourself in the Boston shaker and you’ll see why it’s so popular.
Despite being popular, the Boston Shaker isn’t without its downsides. As a professional bartender you’ll find that the Boston style shaker requires a separate strainer like a Hawthorne to filter out ice and other solid ingredients from your cocktail.
This means you’ll have an extra piece of equipment to manage, clean and possibly replace.
While the Boston shaker is a must have for many behind the bar, this can be a bit of a pain especially during a busy shift.
Your personal preference may sway you towards simpler all-in-one options if you prioritise convenience and speed.
Ultimately, whether the Boston shaker is for you depends on how you balance its pros against these practical considerations.
If you’re leaning towards a Boston shaker you’ll love its larger capacity to mix multiple drinks at once.
Since its a two-piece design you’ll also find it’s easier to clean.
Its versatility and durability makes it a reliable choice for a fast paced bar.
One of the main advantages of choosing a Boston shaker over a Cobbler shaker is its larger capacity. This is a game changer if you work in a busy bar.
With a Boston shaker you can mix multiple drinks at once, greatly increasing your productivity during peak hours.
Unlike the Cobbler shaker which is more suited for individual cocktails, the Boston shaker’s big size allows you to handle the high volume with ease.
When choosing between a Boston shaker and a Cobbler shaker, consider the ease of cleaning—a crucial factor for both home enthusiasts and professional bartenders.
The Boston shaker, a two-piece shaker, stands out for its simplicity and straightforward design. Unlike the three-piece Cobbler shaker which has a built-in strainer and a cap that can trap ingredients and create more cleaning hassle, the Boston shaker has only two cups.
This minimalistic design means fewer crevices for ingredients to get stuck and less time spent scrubbing small parts.
You’ll love how quickly you can rinse and wipe it down, making it a favourite among many professional bartenders who value efficiency and simplicity in their tools.
While the Boston shaker may seem simple with its two-piece design, its versatility really shines especially when making cocktails that require vigorous shaking.
It excels at mixing drinks with egg whites, with plenty of room for aeration and getting the perfect frothy texture.
Professional bartenders prefer the Boston shaker for its adaptability in cocktail making. Unlike the Cobbler shaker which can be restrictive due to its smaller volume and built-in strainer, the Boston shaker has more room to shake up complex cocktails.
This makes it a must have for creative mixology, you can experiment with different ingredients and techniques without limitations.
Considering the demands of frequent use in a busy bar, you’ll appreciate that Boston shakers are more durable and reliable than their Cobbler counterparts.
The best Boston shaker has a simpler design with fewer parts, less chance of something breaking or malfunctioning. This is important because many professional bartenders rely on a good shaker to withstand the daily cocktail mixing.
In contrast, while nice for its built-in strainer, the Cobbler shaker has more parts that can wear out or get stuck. This difference makes a big impact on durability and reliability, putting the Boston shaker ahead in these areas.
A Boston shaker outpaces the Cobbler when it comes to speed and efficiency, it’s a top choice among professional bartenders.
You’ll find that a Boston shaker allows for quicker mixing and pouring without the built-in strainer which often slows down the process in a Cobbler shaker. This means you can serve drinks faster, keep up with the high demands of a busy bar.
It’s especially useful when you’re handling a rush of orders.
For you, the cocktail fan or home bartender, mastering the Boston shaker may take some practice but the payoff in speed is worth it.
Once you get the hang of it you’ll be mixing drinks faster than ever, impressing your guests and upping your mixology skills.
Now let’s look at the Cobbler shaker, known for its unique design and built-in strainer. The Cobbler shaker is a favourite among home bartenders, but professionals might point out some flaws.
We’ll go through the pros and cons to see if this type of shaker is for you.
While the Cobbler shaker’s design might appeal to you because of its simplicity, its functionality really shines for beginners.
This three-piece design consists of a main body which holds the cocktail ingredients, topped with a lid that has a built-in strainer and a cap to close it all up.
The built-in strainer makes it easy, no need to use a separate tool to filter out ice and other solid ingredients.
The whole package makes the Cobbler shaker very beginner friendly, you don’t have to juggle multiple pieces of equipment.
It’s streamlined so you can focus more on mastering your cocktail craft without worrying about the complexity of a professional setup.
Go for the Cobbler over the Boston shaker if you like convenience and style in your cocktail mixing.
Despite its stylish design and all-in-one functionality the Cobbler shaker isn’t without its flaws. You might find the small capacity limiting especially when you’re looking to mix large batches or complex cocktails with multiple ingredients.
The Cobbler’s built-in strainer also has issues; it’s not always effective at keeping bits out of your drink so you might have to strain your cocktail twice. Also, cleaning the Cobbler shaker can be a pain. It has more parts than other types of shakers so more time spent scrubbing after a busy night.
If you’re running a high-volume bar these can be major slowdowns.
When you’re using a Cobbler shaker you’ll find the cap sticks annoyingly tight after shaking making it hard to open.
The built-in strainer might seem convenient but it limits the smoothness of your pour and can clog with finer ingredients.
And losing the small cap is a common annoyance and the overall design presents more challenges for cleaning compared to other types of shakers.
While the Cobbler shaker looks sleek with its three-piece design it’s not without its problems.
One of the main sticking issues you’ll face is when the metal contracts. This happens because the cold from the ice causes the metal to shrink creating a vacuum effect that makes it hard to separate the parts.
This can be frustrating especially if you’re working in a busy bar.
Here’s a quick rundown:
If you’re using a Cobbler shaker you’ll notice the built-in strainer presents several issues. The strainer limitations become apparent with larger holes which sometimes allows ice shards and fine ingredients to slip through making messy pours. This can be a real pain when you’re going for a clean presentation in your cocktail.
And if you’re working with muddled fruits or herbs these can easily clog the strainer cap making the shaking process complicated and affecting the consistency of the drink.
Getting a precise strain becomes a struggle, you might have to double strain the cocktail which adds to your workload and complicates what should be a simple task.
Beyond the strainer issues the other common problem with the Cobbler shaker is the cap. The small metal cap on your Cobbler cocktail shaker is easy to lose and can fly off during shaking. This is usually due to the pressure build up from the ice chips and liquid inside.
Here’s a quick rundown of the cap issues:
Although the Cobbler shaker looks convenient for its all-in-one design its multiple parts present cleaning challenges.
Residues from ingredients like syrups and egg whites stick to the strainer and lid. This can be a real problem if you’re using sticky or fibrous ingredients.
Cleaning each part—cap, strainer and cup—means more nooks and crannies for residue to hide.
Stainless steel shakers can withstand rigorous scrubbing but glass shakers are more delicate and need to be handled with care to avoid breakage.
You need to fully dismantle and clean each part after use so no old mixtures spoil your next cocktail.
Many bartenders find the Cobbler shaker’s limited capacity a major drawback especially when making cocktails in bulk or using voluminous ingredients like egg whites.
In a busy cocktail bar efficiency and speed is key and the Cobbler shaker isn’t always up to the task. Its smaller volume means you’re making drinks one at a time which isn’t ideal during a rush.
While it’s one of the best cocktail shakers for home use or smaller settings due to its ease of use in a professional environment this can hinder your ability to serve customers quickly.
This makes larger capacity shakers like the Boston more suitable for high-volume situations and a professional bartender’s choice.
While the Cobbler shaker seems like a practical choice for your home bar it’s worth noting the significant variability in quality among different brands. This can affect your cocktail mixing experience.
Here are some common issues:
When stocking your bar cart consider these factors along with the French shaker or other shakers.
Now the French shaker, it’s a chic combination of style and function, often praised for its design and simplicity.
Unlike other shakers the French shaker is only two pieces — metal bottom and metal cap — so it’s easier to handle and clean.
But you might find it’s not as fool-proof as the Cobbler when it comes to preventing leaks during shaking.
If you prefer a sleek all-metal option consider the French shaker, known for its two-piece design.
Unlike the Boston shaker which often comes with a mixing glass the French shaker (also called Parisian shaker) is all metal. This makes it more durable.
You’ll find it a tighter fit than even the best Cobbler shaker so less mess and more efficient mixing.
Building on the French shaker’s unique features it’s clear its all-metal design boosts its longevity.
This type of shaker not only looks sleek and stylish adding to your bar’s aesthetic but also durable enough for heavy use.
You’ll find the metal lid seals tight so no spills when you shake your cocktails, a smoother mix with your bar spoon.
While the French shaker brings style and durability to your bartending arsenal it’s not without flaws.
When comparing the weights of Boston and French shakers you’ll find both are designed to balance heft and manageability.
Boston shakers like the Cocktail Kingdom Koriko Weighted Shaking Tins weigh around 447 grams. Their solid construction adds weight so the shaker feels solid in your hand as you mix drinks.
A standard French shaker weighs around 430 grams. The slight difference in weight means you won’t feel weighed down even during a long bartending shift.
Both have enough weight to mix cocktails without needing a separate measuring cup.
| Shaker Type | Description | Pros✅ | Cons❌ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cobbler Shaker | Three-piece design with built-in strainer and cap. | All-in-One Design: Simplifies mixing process. Built-in Strainer: No need for extra tools. Aesthetic Appeal: Improves bar appearance. Durable: Metal construction. | Small Capacity: Limited for large batches. Difficult Cleaning: More parts to clean. Strainer Issues: May not filter effectively. Sticking Cap: Can be hard to open. |
| Boston Shaker | Two-piece design with separate glass and metal tin. | Large Capacity: Mixes multiple drinks at once. Easy Cleaning: Simple two-piece design. Versatile: Suitable for complex cocktails. Durable: Reliable for frequent use. | Requires Separate Strainer: Extra equipment needed. Tight Seal: Can be hard to separate after shaking. |
| French Shaker | Similar to Boston but often more aesthetically pleasing. | Sleek Design: Upscale appearance. Durable: Long-lasting construction. | Requires Separate Strainer: Extra tool needed. Less Common: May not be as widely available. |
In summary choosing the right cocktail shaker depends on your bartending style and needs.
The Boston Shaker is versatile and many pros favour it for its simplicity and efficiency.
The Cobbler shaker’s built-in strainer is convenient but can jam.
The French shaker is stylish and comparable in weight to the Boston.
Knowing these nuances will help you choose the perfect shaker to improve your cocktail skills.
Stay connected with Ascot Wholesale for more insights, tips, and industry trends. Whether you’re looking to elevate your business or simply stay informed, we’ve got you covered.
Contact us to learn how we can support your business with our extensive range of quality products and exceptional service or, explore more blogs for additional valuable content.
