Which Shaker to Choose? Boston, Cobbler, or French?

When starting out with mixology you may have asked yourself the question: Which shaker to choose? Getting to know the types of cocktail shaker will help you produce your next masterpiece.

So choosing the right shaker—Boston, Cobbler, or French will boil down to experience and requirements. If you’re new to cocktail-making, the Cobbler shaker’s built-in strainer and ease of use make it the way to go.

For the experienced pros, the Boston shaker offers versatility and durability for all cocktails—or the French shaker offers style and performance for those who prioritise both.

Read on to find which one matches your bartending goals the best.

Summary

• Boston shakers are for pros because of their versatility and high volume.
• Cobbler shakers are for beginners with a user friendly design and built in strainer.
• French shakers are for those who want style and functionality in their barware.
• Choose a Boston shaker if you need durability and are experienced in cocktail making.
• Opt for a Cobbler shaker if you want convenience and simplicity for home use.

Shaker Overview

The perfect cocktail shaker is essential for any aspiring mixologist or seasoned bartender. You have three to choose from: Boston, Cobbler, and French. Each has its own unique features and benefits.

The Boston shaker, two cups that fit together, is preferred by pros for its versatility and durability. If you’re starting or want a more straightforward setup, the Cobbler shaker, with built in strainer and cap, might be your best bet. For those who want style and tradition, the French shaker, a two piece set like the Boston but with more charm, is the way to go.

Best For: Professional bartenders and those who want a classic versatile tool for cocktails.

Boston Shaker

Now let’s look at the Boston Shaker. It’s a favourite among pros. Glass and metal tin, you can see your cocktail as you mix. But it’s trickier to master and not the best for beginners.

Description

When venturing into mixology you’ll come across the Boston shaker, a favourite among professional bartenders for its simplicity and efficiency.

This type of shaker has a simple two piece construction:

• Metal Tin: Used for the vigorous shaking of ingredients.
• Glass or Second Tin: Fits into the metal tin to form a snug seal, perfect for mixing drinks without spills.
• Versatility: Good for all cocktail recipes, makes it a top choice for pros.

Unlike the Cobbler shaker which has a built in strainer, the Boston shaker requires more skill to master, especially when separating the two pieces after shaking.

Boston Pros:

If you’re going to mix cocktails like a pro, the Boston shaker is a must have tool in your arsenal.

This type of shaker has two parts: metal tin and glass or second tin, which is very versatile. It’s a staple in professional bars and preferred by many bartenders for high volume use, making it perfect for busy environments.

It allows for more vigorous shaking, perfect for many cocktail recipes. And it’s simplicity and efficiency makes it an essential tool for both new and experienced mixologists to hone their skills.

Boston Cons

Although the Boston Shaker is celebrated for its versatility and professional appeal, it has a couple of downsides you should consider.

Here are the main Boston cons:

• Skilled Required: Master the Boston shaker isn’t easy. You’ll need to practice sealing and separating the two pieces smoothly, especially the one tin and one glass model.
• Separate Strainer Needed: Boston requires a separate strainer, unlike other shakers. This means another piece of equipment to buy and clean.
• Double Straining Often Necessary: Double straining is often required when using a Boston shaker, adding another step to your cocktail process to get a smoother cocktail.

Cobbler Shaker

Now let’s talk about the Cobbler shaker, a favourite for beginners and seasoned mixologists. It has three parts: tin, built in strainer and cap, which makes it convenient but has pros and cons.

Because of the integrated components it’s easier to use but not as versatile as other shakers.

Description

The Cobbler shaker is a favourite for beginners because of the built in strainer which makes the cocktail-making process easier.

Here’s why it’s one of the best shakers for those just starting:

• User Friendly Design: The built in strainer eliminates the need for a separate tool, makes the cocktail-making neater and quicker.
• Versatile: Good for many cocktails, from simple shaken drinks to more complex recipes.
• Ease of Use: Unlike the two piece Boston or the more complex three piece shaker, the Cobbler’s three piece design is simple, less intimidating for beginners.

You can shake and strain confidently, and enjoy the cocktail process.

Cobbler Pros

If you’re a beginner making cocktails, a Cobbler Shaker has several advantages that makes it a good choice. Its ease of use is a highlight.

It has a built in strainer that makes the mixing and pouring process easier. You won’t need to fumble with separate pieces; everything is self contained. This is perfect for beginners who might feel overwhelmed by more complex setups.

Plus the Cobbler shaker has a vintage look that can add some charm to your home bar. Its classic design serves a practical function and improves the look of your space, making it a stylish and functional addition to your cocktail tool box.

Cobbler Cons

While the Cobbler shaker is great for beginners, it has downsides especially on capacity and strain quality.

Here are three main cons to consider:

• Limited Capacity: Good for single serves, not practical for large batches or parties. You’ll be shaking cocktails one at a time, which isn’t efficient for multiple guests.
• Strain Quality: The built in strainer often doesn’t filter out fine particles. You might need to double strain to get a smoother texture, adding an extra step to your cocktail process.
• Personal Preference: Although popular among certain styles, the cobbler shaker might not fit everyone’s preference, especially those who want fast and efficient cocktail making.

French Shaker

Now let’s talk about the French shaker. It’s a two piece shaker, simple and elegant which might suit your bartending style. But while it’s beautiful, it has pros and cons in practical use.

Description

The French shaker has an all metal design that combines style with functionality, it’s a beautiful addition to any bar setup. Unlike the Cobbler shaker, this shaker requires a separate strainer, perfect for experienced bartenders who like to have a hands on approach.

Here’s why it’s a winner:

• All Metal Construction: Durable and sleek professional look.
• Sleek Design: For those who care about aesthetics in their barware.
• Separate Strainer Required: Adds a level of skill, appealing to more experienced bartenders.

Whether you’re mixing a martini or crafting a complex cocktail, the French shaker with its distinctive metal tin is designed to impress while providing the precision and flexibility to make perfect drinks.

French Pros

With its all metal design and sleek looks, the French shaker also has functional advantages. It’s a three piece shaker, a classic in professional settings. The tight seal means you won’t have to deal with spills as you mix your drinks, a relief especially when making cocktails in a busy bar.

The French shaker isn’t just about practicality, it fits seamlessly into any upscale bar cart, looks great. This shaker is super durable and can withstand heavy use without loosing its charm.

The French shaker might be the tool to combine efficiency and style in cocktail making.

French Cons

While the French shaker has its advantages, consider its downsides especially if you’re new to cocktail making.

Here are the French cons to weigh:

• Skill Required: More difficult to open and close, can be frustrating if you’re not yet skilled with cocktail shakers.
• Separate Strainer Needed: Unlike the Cobbler shaker, this one requires an external strainer, adds an extra step and expense to cocktail making.
• Smaller Glass Compatibility: The French shaker might not fit larger or irregularly shaped glasses, limits its versatility.

For many experienced bartenders it’s a great choice. Still these points might influence your decision depending on your skill level and needs.

Choose the Right Shaker

When choosing a shaker, consider who will use it and for what purpose.If you’re a beginner, go for a Cobbler shaker for ease and built in strainer. Professionals often prefer the versatility and capacity of a Boston shaker.

The French shaker stands out for durability and style. Its all metal design appeals to those who value style as much as function.

For Beginners

The Cobbler shaker is the way to go if you’re just starting mixology. It’s especially friendly for beginners due to its simple design and functionality.

Here’s why:

• Built-in Strainer: No need for a separate straining device, makes cocktail making smoother.
• Ease of Use: All in one design means you don’t have to juggle multiple pieces like a Boston shaker.
• Versatility: Perfect for a wide range of cocktails that need shaking rather than stirring with a mixing glass.

Choose a Cobbler shaker and you’ll feel more confident as you learn, less intimidating when making homemade cocktails.

For Professionals

As a professional mixologist you’ll likely prefer the Boston shaker for its great versatility and capacity, perfect for making many drinks.

This two piece cocktail shaker, known for its simplicity and effectiveness, is a classic in any cocktail bar. It’s a large glass and metal tin, for quick chilling and mixing of ingredients.

While the best cobbler shaker might seem tempting with its built in strainer, the Boston Shaker offers more control and faster workflow, which is key in a busy environment.

For Durability and Style

The French shaker, often praised for its elegant shape and robust construction, is the choice for those who value durability and style in their barware. Also known as the Parisian shaker, it combines the practicality of the Boston shaker with the convenience of the Cobbler’s strainer, it’s a favourite in the cocktail world.

Here’s why you should get one:

• Sleek Design: Its streamlined look isn’t just for show; it’s designed to be functional and beautiful.
• Built-In Durability: Made for heavy use, it can withstand the demands of a busy bar.
• Integrated Strainer: Simplifies your toolkit by having a strainer, makes it more user friendly and efficient.

Last Orders

Now that you know the ins and outs of Boston, Cobbler and French shakers, picture yourself shaking a cocktail with the right shaker. Whether it’s the Boston, the Cobbler or the French, your choice will elevate your mixology skills. Each shaker blends ingredients and your style into every glass.

Choose well, shake bold and enjoy your masterpiece!

Related Articles

• Boston vs Cobbler vs French Shaker: Pros and Cons